I get two kinds of question about Passivhaus. One comes from people planning a new house who have read about the standard and want to know whether it is realistic. The other, more often, comes from people living in a draughty 1930s or Victorian house who want it to be warm, and want to know whether Passivhaus is worth it or an expensive distraction.
The answer is different for each, and in Surrey the planning position often decides it. If you want the background on what the standard is and how it is measured, the Passivhaus standard explained covers it. This post is about the decision.
Is Passivhaus worth it on a new build?
Yes, if it shapes the design from the first sketch. If not, I would not bother chasing the certificate.
Passivhaus rewards a simple, compact form, windows sized and placed for the orientation, and construction details worked out before a builder is appointed. On a new house all of that is in your hands, and the extra cost goes into insulation, windows, airtightness and ventilation, not into undoing earlier decisions.
A house designed conventionally and then asked to become Passivhaus late on usually ends up with compromises everywhere: walls thicker than the plan allowed for, windows the wrong size for the sun, a ventilation system with nowhere to run its ducts.
New homes in England will have to meet the Future Homes Standard from 24 March 2027, which in practice means low-carbon heating instead of a gas boiler. Passivhaus goes a long way further, and it is a choice, not a requirement. The new build homes page sets out how I approach a new house.
Passivhaus and planning in Surrey
Thicker walls make a house bigger on the outside for the same rooms inside. A compact form with carefully placed windows may not look like the houses around it.
In the Green Belt, which covers much of the countryside around Woking and Guildford, councils watch the size of a replacement or new house closely, so every extra 100 millimetres of wall counts. In the Surrey Hills National Landscape, appearance is weighed just as carefully. Neither rules out a Passivhaus. Both mean the performance has to be part of the planning case from the beginning, not argued for afterwards.
Is Passivhaus worth it for an existing house?
For most existing homes, full certification, or the refurbishment version of the standard called EnerPHit, is a high bar. The principles are still the right guide, and the order is the part people most often get wrong.
Airtightness and ventilation go together. Sealing up a house without a planned way of getting fresh air in is how you get condensation and mould. Mechanical ventilation with heat recovery (MVHR), which brings in fresh air and warms it with the heat from the stale air going out, is the Passivhaus answer. It needs space for ducts, which is far easier to find during a renovation than afterwards.
Insulation has to suit the walls. The solid brick walls of many older Surrey houses need insulation that lets moisture move, or water gets trapped inside the wall. Cavity walls, timber frames and modern blockwork each have their own answers.
Windows go in with the insulation, not before it. New windows fitted years before the walls are insulated often end up in the wrong position in the wall, and the junction leaks heat.
Heating comes last. Once the house loses less heat, the heating system can be smaller. Air source heat pumps work best in a house that has already been insulated. Heating options for a renovation goes into the choice in more detail.

Do I need planning permission for a heat pump?
Often not. In England, most air source heat pumps on houses are permitted development, and the rules were relaxed in May 2025: the old requirement to keep the unit a metre from the boundary went, larger units are allowed, and a detached house can have two. The unit still has to meet the installer standard on noise.
Conservation areas and listed buildings are different. There are extra limits on where a unit can go in a conservation area, and on a listed building you will usually need listed building consent. Check before you order anything.
Conservation areas and older houses
Many Surrey towns and villages have conservation areas, and a lot of the county’s housing is older and attractive. External wall insulation changes how a house looks and will usually need planning permission in a conservation area. On a listed building almost any change to the fabric needs listed building consent, and replacement windows in a conservation area may be controlled too.
That does not rule out a warm house. It means internal insulation, careful secondary glazing and airtightness work often do more of the job, and the approach has to be agreed with the council. The heritage and conservation page sets out how that conversation usually goes.
The builder matters as much as the design
Passivhaus-level performance is won or lost on site. Airtightness depends on someone taping every joint and sealing round every pipe and cable, and the only way to know it has been done is to test it.
If you are aiming high, choose a builder who has done airtight work before or is willing to learn it properly, and build at least one air test into the programme before the walls are closed up, while leaks can still be found and fixed. A test at the very end tells you how well it went. A test in the middle lets you do something about it. Choosing the right builder has the questions to ask.
So, is Passivhaus worth it?
The thinking behind it, needing less heat instead of generating more, is right for almost every house. Whether you want the certificate is a separate question.
For a new build designed from scratch, the discipline can be worth it, and the certificate proves the house does what it says. For most renovations in Surrey, the useful target is a house that is warm, dry and quiet and uses less energy than it did, done in the right order, without chasing a number for its own sake.
I am trained in low-energy design and a member of the AECB, and that is the conversation I would want to have about your house: what is realistic for this building, in this place, within this budget. If you want formal certification, that brings in a certified Passivhaus designer and an independent certifier, and the decision needs making at the start. The Passive House design and retrofit page explains how I approach it.
The free 15-minute Clarity Call is the place to start if you are deciding how far to go.
Questions people ask about Passivhaus homes
Can an existing house be certified Passivhaus? Rarely in full. The refurbishment version of the standard, EnerPHit, exists because an older house cannot usually reach new-build figures, and even that is a high bar for a Victorian or 1930s house in Surrey. The principles still apply: airtightness and ventilation planned together, insulation that suits the walls, windows fitted in line with the insulation, and the heating sized last. Done in that order, most houses end up warm, dry and quiet without anyone chasing a certificate.
Does a Passivhaus need thicker walls? Usually, yes, because of the extra insulation, and in Surrey that has a planning consequence. Thicker walls make a house bigger on the outside for the same rooms inside, and in the Green Belt councils watch the size of a new or replacement house closely, so every extra 100 millimetres counts. In the Surrey Hills National Landscape appearance is weighed just as carefully. Neither rules out a Passivhaus, but the performance case has to be part of the planning application from the start.
Do I need a specialist builder for a Passivhaus? Not necessarily a specialist, but a builder who has done airtight work before or is willing to learn it properly. Passivhaus performance is won or lost on site: someone has to tape every joint and seal round every pipe and cable, and the only way to know it has been done is to test it. Build at least one air test into the programme before the walls are closed up, while leaks can still be found. Choosing the right builder has the questions to ask.










