Heating is usually one of the last things people think about in a renovation, and one of the first things they notice when they move back in. The new kitchen extension that is cold in January. The open-plan room where the radiators can’t keep up. The heat pump that was supposed to bring the bills down and hasn’t.
Most of those problems were decided months earlier, when the layout and the glazing were fixed and the heating was left for the plumber to sort out. The heating options for a renovation are easy to get right if they are thought about at the same time as everything else.
Start with the heat you lose
Before choosing any system, it helps to know how much heat the house needs, and that depends on how much it loses: through the roof, walls, floor, windows and gaps. A proper heat loss calculation, room by room, is the starting point for sizing any heating system. It is also the clearest way to see where the effort is best spent.

The Chobham bungalow renovation: fabric first, then the heating. Photograph: Darren Chung.
In most older Surrey houses, the big losses are through the roof, the ground floor, old windows and draughts. Dealing with those first, before replacing the heating, means the system can be smaller and will work better. It is sometimes called “fabric first”. It isn’t glamorous, but it is the order that works. Retrofitting an older house goes through it step by step.
A renovation changes the heat loss too. A new extension with large glazing adds a lot. A loft conversion adds rooms right under the roof. Knocking through creates a big space that one radiator was never going to heat. Open-plan living is lovely until it is cold, so all of that needs to be in the calculation.
Should I keep a gas boiler?
A gas boiler is still the most common choice, and for some renovations it is still the sensible one for now, particularly where the work is modest or phased over several years. Nothing currently stops you replacing a gas boiler in an existing home. The Future Homes Standard, which moves new homes off gas boilers from March 2027, applies to new houses, not to renovations. On our tenders from 2025 and 2026, a boiler and hot water cylinder together have come in at £4,700 to £5,400, excluding VAT and rounded.
What a boiler doesn’t do is prepare the house for the future. If you are renovating extensively, design the system so a heat pump could follow later: larger radiators or underfloor heating, space for a hot water cylinder, and pipework sized to suit. That way the next change doesn’t mean ripping out the last one.
Will a heat pump work in an older house?
Often, yes, if the house is ready for it. An air source heat pump takes heat from the outside air and moves it into the house. It is efficient, but it works differently from a boiler. It runs at lower water temperatures for longer, which means the house needs to hold its heat well and the radiators or underfloor heating need to be sized for those lower temperatures.
When a heat pump disappoints, it is usually because one of those things wasn’t true. The house was too leaky, the radiators too small, or the system was sized by rule of thumb, not by calculation.
A few practical points come up on almost every project. There needs to be room outside for the unit, away from bedroom windows and with some thought for neighbours and noise. There needs to be space inside for a hot water cylinder. And the installer should be MCS certified, which is required for the government’s Boiler Upgrade Scheme grant towards replacing a fossil fuel system with a heat pump.
Ground source heat pumps are more efficient again, but need either a large garden for pipes laid in trenches or a borehole. They are more common on new builds and larger plots.
Do I need planning permission for a heat pump?
Usually not. Many air source heat pumps can be installed as permitted development, and in May 2025 the rules in England were relaxed: the requirement to keep the unit a metre from the boundary was removed, larger units are allowed, and a detached house can have two. Conservation areas and listed buildings still carry extra limits, so check before you commit. Is Passivhaus worth it for a Surrey home? covers the conservation area side in more detail.
Are there grants or tax breaks?
Two help. The Boiler Upgrade Scheme gives a grant in England and Wales towards a heat pump that replaces a gas, oil, LPG or electric system. Most new builds are not eligible, and the amount and rules are set out on gov.uk, so check them when you are ready to order.
And installing energy-saving materials in a home, including heat pumps, insulation and solar panels, is currently zero-rated for VAT, until 31 March 2027, when it is due to go to 5%. The rules on what counts are specific, so ask your installer how they will invoice it.
Underfloor heating in an extension
Underfloor heating suits heat pumps well, because it runs at low temperatures across a large surface. It is particularly good in kitchen extensions and open-plan rooms, where all the glazing leaves little wall for radiators.
It does need planning early. The floor build-up has to allow for insulation, pipes and screed, which affects floor levels and thresholds. It responds slowly, so it suits steady background heat better than quick bursts. And fitted kitchens, thick rugs and built-in furniture all reduce the area that gives off heat.
Ventilation, the part people forget
As a house becomes more airtight, ventilation matters more. Without it, moisture from cooking, showers and breathing has nowhere to go, and you get condensation and mould. Building regulations require adequate ventilation in new work, through extractor fans, trickle vents or a whole-house system.
In a well-insulated house or a major renovation, mechanical ventilation with heat recovery (MVHR) is worth considering. It supplies fresh air and recovers most of the heat from the stale air going out. It needs space for the unit and the ducts, so like everything else here, it has to be designed in early.
What the building regulations ask
Part L of the building regulations covers energy efficiency, and its standards were raised in 2022. New extensions have to meet insulation and glazing standards, and replacement heating systems have efficiency and controls requirements. Part F covers ventilation. In practice that means the energy performance has to be designed into the drawings, not added at the end. Planning permission vs building regulations explains how the two sets of rules differ.
Getting the order right
The sequence I would follow is simple. Work out the heat loss of the house as it will be after the renovation. Reduce it where you can, starting with the least disruptive measures. Then choose a heating system sized for what is left, and design the radiators or underfloor heating, the controls and the ventilation around it.
That is the approach behind my Passivhaus design and retrofit work, though it applies to any renovation whether or not you are aiming for a certificate. The Clarity Pack includes initial comments on comfort and heating alongside the layout options, so the heating route is known before the drawings are fixed.
If you aren’t sure which heating route suits your house, the free 15-minute Clarity Call is a good first step.
Questions people ask about heating a renovated house
Do radiators need replacing for a heat pump? Often some of them do. A heat pump runs at lower water temperatures for longer than a boiler, so each radiator has to give off enough heat at that lower temperature, which usually means larger radiators in some rooms, or underfloor heating. A room-by-room heat loss calculation tells you which. If you are keeping a boiler for now, fitting the larger radiators, the cylinder space and the pipework anyway means a heat pump can follow later without ripping it all out.
Why is my new extension cold in winter? Usually because the heating was decided after the layout and the glazing were fixed, and left for the plumber to size by rule of thumb. A new extension with large glazing adds a lot of heat loss, and knocking through creates a big space that one radiator was never going to heat. The fix starts with a heat loss calculation for the house as it will be after the work, then radiators or underfloor heating sized to match.
What does fabric first mean? Dealing with the building before the heating. In most older Surrey houses the big losses are through the roof, the ground floor, old windows and draughts, and sorting those first means the heating system can be smaller and will work better, whether it is a boiler or a heat pump. It isn’t glamorous, but it is the order that works. Retrofitting an older house goes through it step by step.










