Journal · 1 October 2025 · Updated 31 October 2026 · Planning and permissions

Six planning permission myths that slow projects down

By James Williamson, Architect & Director

A 3D visualisation of an open-plan kitchen, dining and living room with rooflights and steel-framed glazed doors onto a garden.

The word I hear most often on a first call about planning permission is “assumed”. We assumed it was permitted development. We assumed that because next door did it, we could. We assumed the neighbours being friendly meant it would go through.

None of those planning myths is unreasonable. Most of them come from something a friend, a builder or a neighbour said in good faith. The trouble is that planning decisions are made against written policy, on your particular house, by an officer who has never met you. When the assumption turns out to be wrong, it usually costs months, not weeks, because the drawings go back to the beginning.

Here are the six I come across most in Surrey, and what actually decides the answer.

Myth 1: “It’s only small, so it won’t need permission”

Size isn’t the test. Permitted development, the national rights that let some work go ahead without an application, depends on the type of house, where it is, what has been built before and what the council has done to those rights locally.

A modest rear extension can need a full application if the house is in a conservation area, if the rights were removed by a condition when the estate was built, or if an earlier owner has already used up some of the allowance. Side extensions, roof extensions and cladding are restricted in conservation areas and in the Surrey Hills. Some councils have Article 4 directions that remove particular rights street by street. None of this shows on the outside of the house.

The fix is cheap and dull: check the planning history of your house and the constraints on the site before anyone designs anything. Do I need planning permission for an extension? walks through those checks. If the answer is permitted development, get a lawful development certificate, the council’s written confirmation that the work is lawful. Your buyer’s solicitor will ask for it one day.

The brick front of a renovated bungalow in Chobham, with white-framed bay windows and a gravel drive.

The Chobham bungalow renovation. Photograph: Darren Chung.

Myth 2: “If the neighbours don’t object, it will be approved”

Neighbours matter, and talking to them early is good manners and good sense. But a planning officer doesn’t approve a scheme because nobody wrote in. They assess it against the local plan and the council’s design guidance: how it looks from the street, whether it overshadows or overlooks next door, whether it sits comfortably against the original house.

It works the other way too. A pile of objections doesn’t mean refusal. Only material planning considerations count, so “it will spoil my view” or “it will lower my house price” carry no weight, while loss of daylight to a kitchen window can carry a great deal.

Myth 3: “Permitted development means we can start straight away”

It doesn’t, for a few reasons. A larger single-storey rear extension under the prior approval route has to be notified to the council, neighbours are consulted, and you wait up to 42 days for the council’s answer. Building regulations apply whatever the planning route, so the structure, insulation and drainage still need approving and inspecting. And if the work is on or near a shared wall, party wall notices have to be served and the notice periods allowed to run.

Permitted development removes one application. It doesn’t remove the sequence. Permitted development vs planning permission covers when each route makes sense, and planning permission vs building regulations explains the second set of approvals.

Myth 4: “Every Surrey council works the same way”

They don’t. Woking, Guildford, Waverley, Surrey Heath, Runnymede, Elmbridge, Mole Valley and the rest each have their own local plan and their own guidance on extensions. Woking publishes its own guidance on daylight, privacy and outlook. Green Belt policy limits how much a house can grow over its original size, and that is judged differently from council to council. The Surrey Hills adds its own layer.

From 1 April 2027 planning in the county moves to two new councils, West Surrey and East Surrey. That won’t make the differences disappear overnight. Until the new councils adopt their own local plans, the existing borough plans and design guidance are expected to carry across. There’s more on what that means for your application on the West Surrey architects page.

A scheme drawn for one borough and dropped into the next can fail on a test the designer never knew was there. The answer is to read the policy for your area, and the decisions on similar houses nearby, before drawing a line.

Myth 5: “If it’s been up for four years, the council can’t touch it”

This one used to be true, and plenty of people still believe it. For building work in England, the council used to lose the power to take enforcement action four years after the work was substantially complete. Since 25 April 2024 that period is ten years. Work finished before that date still falls under the old four-year rule, but anything built since is exposed for a decade.

It matters most when you sell. A buyer’s solicitor will want to see permission or a certificate for anything that needed one, and “it’s been there for years” is a much weaker answer than it used to be.

Myth 6: “A refusal is the end of it”

A refusal is a written list of the council’s reasons. You can amend the scheme and apply again, or you can appeal to the Planning Inspectorate, which is independent of the council. For a householder application the appeal has to be lodged within 12 weeks of the decision. Which route is sensible depends on the reasons given.

For what it’s worth, 98% of the sites we have taken through planning since 2020 gained permission in the end: 79 of 81. Planning figures cover 108 decisions on 81 sites, March 2020 to October 2026, from council notices and our own records. Three appeals were allowed. “In the end” is doing real work in that sentence. Some of those sites needed a second application or an appeal, and nobody can promise you a result on yours. What the record does show is that a refusal is usually a problem to solve, not a verdict.

How do you avoid planning delays?

The projects that move without drama are rarely the simplest ones. They are the ones where the questions were asked in the right order. Planning history and site constraints first. Then the planning route. Then a design shaped around the tests the council will apply, with the awkward ones, such as daylight to next door, dealt with on the drawings before anyone else raises them. Then the application, with a realistic expectation of 8 to 12 weeks for a decision once it is validated.

Planning permission is permission, not proof that the design works. It is one step in a longer sequence, and it goes better when it’s treated that way. If your house is in a conservation area, heritage and conservation explains the extra layer, and planning advice and feasibility is how I test a site before anything is drawn.

If you’re not sure which of these applies to you, the free 15-minute Clarity Call is a good place to start.

Questions people ask about planning permission

How long does planning permission take for a house extension? Councils usually decide a householder application 8 to 12 weeks after they have validated it, and the clock does not start until it is valid. Under the larger home extension route for a single-storey rear extension, the council has up to 42 days to answer. The time before the application is often longer: checking the planning history and site constraints, then designing around the tests the council will apply. A scheme that goes back to the beginning after a refusal costs months, which is why the checks come first.

Can neighbours stop my planning application? Not on their own. Objections are read, but only material planning considerations count, so “it will spoil my view” or “it will lower my house price” carry no weight, while loss of daylight to a kitchen window can carry a great deal. The officer judges the scheme against the local plan and the council’s design guidance, not the number of letters. It still pays to talk to neighbours early, and to deal with the awkward points, such as overlooking, on the drawings before anyone raises them.

What happens if you build without planning permission? The council can take enforcement action, and the window for that is longer than it used to be. For work in England finished since 25 April 2024, the period is ten years, not four. You can apply retrospectively and the council judges it like any other application, but nobody can promise the outcome. It also surfaces when you sell: a buyer’s solicitor will want to see permission or a certificate for anything that needed one, and “it’s been there for years” is a weak answer now.

Journal by email

New articles, sent to you

New posts, a few times a month. No fees, no selling. Unsubscribe in one click.

We use your details only to send you the journal, as described in our privacy policy, and never share them.

The service this relates to

The cover photograph of Your Dream Home: a bright kitchen extension in Walthamstow

Free guide

Your Dream Home

Doing this for the first time? Thirty-eight pages on getting the order right: the five mistakes to avoid, what it really costs in Surrey, how planning works and how long it takes, with two worksheets to fill in.

Get the free guide

If you are weighing this up for your own home

Fifteen minutes on the phone with James. There is no pressure and no obligation. Sometimes the right outcome of a call is simply a clearer head.

Book a free 15-minute Clarity Call (opens in a new tab)

James calls you at the time you pick. You describe the house and what you want to do; he tells you what he would do first and whether a Clarity Pack is worth it. No preparation needed.

No selling. Just a clear view on the smartest next step. Prefer to write? Send a short note.

Accreditations

  • RIBA Chartered Practice
  • ARB registered architect, registration number 088216J
  • AECB member
  • Passivhaus Trust member
  • LABC Registered Partner, Partner Authority Scheme
  • Woking Chamber of Commerce member

Enlarged picture